How to Navigate the Most Critical Season in a Leader’s Life Without Crashing

Written By Catherine Fitzgerald
 

How to Navigate the Most Critical Season in a Leader’s Life Without Crashing

A Guide for Pastors and Ministry Leaders by Ken Roberts

"The prudent see danger and take refuge, but the simple keep going and pay the penalty." — Proverbs 22:3

Every ministry leader hits a stretch of road that feels more like a minefield than a mission. A place where vision feels foggy, passion fades, and spiritual health starts to slip. For some, it begins subtly. For others, it’s a crash with no warning.

Welcome to what I call the Caution or Crisis Zone—the most critical season in a leader’s life.

What Is the Caution or Crisis Zone?

The Caution/Crisis Zone is a prolonged season of internal struggle and external challenge that nearly every pastor or ministry leader will face. It’s the spiritual wilderness, the emotional valley, the dry season of leadership. In Eugene Peterson’s words, it's "the badlands"—a raw and often painful stretch where God strips away illusions, idols, and false identities.

In this zone, leaders either:

  • Get stuck

  • Flame out

  • Or break through

This season can make or break your leadership future—and your soul.

How Leaders End Up in the Crisis Zone

Not all leaders arrive here the same way, but there are typically three paths that lead to this point:

1. Self-Inflicted Wounds

Poor decisions catch up. Character cracks become chasms. Unaddressed issues—like pride, isolation, burnout, addiction, moral compromise, or emotional immaturity—start to pull your leadership down.

2. Pain from Others' Choices

Sometimes it’s not your sin—it’s someone else’s. A child goes astray. Staff members betray. A denominational shift leaves you stranded. Relationships rupture. You didn’t cause the crisis, but you’re still caught in the fallout.

3. Unexpected Tragedy

Loss. Grief. Health crises. Accidents. These life-altering blows come out of nowhere and shake your foundation. For me, it was the sudden death of my wife in a car accident. That moment launched me into a personal and professional wilderness I never saw coming.

Three Common Responses to Crisis (Only One Leads to Healing)

Every leader in the Crisis Zone faces a fork in the road. Your response here determines whether you flame out or find breakthrough.

1. The Religious Option – Perform, Don’t Transform

This leader keeps showing up, preaching sermons, quoting Scripture, and “powering through” with spiritual clichés—but never really deals with the deeper issues. They avoid counseling, coaching, or vulnerability.

“The devil is attacking me, but God is good!” becomes the band-aid that hides the wound, but never heals it.

This road leads to bitterness, burnout, and becoming the type of older leader no one wants to become—jaded, cynical, and angry.

2. The Ditch Option – Blow It All Up

This is the story we hear too often:

  • Moral failure

  • Porn addiction

  • Burnout and resignation

  • Financial compromise

  • Substance abuse

  • Emotional meltdowns

Leaders don’t plan to crash—they drift there through years of unattended pain and soul neglect. And while God can redeem anyone, the carnage left behind is real, lasting, and often devastating.

3. The Transformational Option – Let God Go Deep

This is the path less taken—but the one that leads to true healing and lasting fruitfulness.

It requires honesty, humility, and courage. It means allowing God to meet you in your weakness and pain—and inviting Him to do a deep, soul-level work.

When you take this road, God begins transforming you in four critical ways.

Find out More about Healthy Leader Coaching

As leaders, we all want to finish well, but knowing what to do in the most critical junctures of leadership can be difficult. We know that the health of you as a leader matters for you and for the organization you lead. Our Healthy Leader coaching will help you understand where you are in your journey as a leader and how to move forward effectively.

Four Transformational Outcomes of the Crisis Season

1. A Rebuilt Identity in Christ

God will strip away every false foundation you’ve built your leadership or self-worth upon. That includes:

  • Performance

  • Platform

  • Praise

  • Titles

  • People-pleasing

“An idol of the heart,” writes Terry Wardle, “is anything we turn to other than God Himself for security, significance, acceptance, and purpose.”

In the Caution/Crisis zone, God invites you to rediscover your true identity: A beloved son or daughter, fully accepted, apart from what you do or what others think of you.

Dr. David Benner reminds us:

“The self we find hidden in Christ is our true self... because Christ is the source of our being and the ground of our true identity.”

2. Emotional Healing and Wholeness

Pain that’s buried is never healed. During this season, God will uncover:

  • Old trauma

  • Shame from past mistakes

  • Grief from unprocessed loss

  • Loneliness from long-term isolation

  • Anger and betrayal

These wounds don’t disqualify you—they become the soil of transformation. The emotional healing you experience will prepare you for deeper ministry, healthier relationships, and more Christlike leadership.

3. Major Paradigm Shifts in Faith and Leadership

The wilderness isn’t just a place of breaking—it’s a place of revelation.

Just as it was for Moses, Paul, and even Jesus, the wilderness can change how you:

  • Understand the grace of God

  • Relate to the Father

  • See yourself

  • Lead others

  • Practice ministry

During my own crisis season, I shifted from a performance-based faith to living out of union with Christ. It changed everything. And it wouldn’t have happened without the valley.

4. Realignment for What’s Next

God doesn’t waste pain. He uses it to:

  • Reposition you

  • Refocus your calling

  • Realign your leadership

  • Reveal your next assignment

This is the Kingdom pattern: Death → Burial → Resurrection.

As you emerge from your crisis season, you’ll find yourself more centered, more grounded, and more aligned with what God has uniquely called you to do.

“Our vocation,” Benner writes, “is grounded in the self that from eternity God has willed that we be.”

The Road Through the Badlands Is Hard—But Worth It

Many leaders never make it through the badlands. Some settle. Some sink. But if you choose the transformational path, there’s healing, purpose, and new life waiting on the other side.

You don’t have to flame out.
You don’t have to fake it.
You don’t have to flee.

You can face this season—and come through it stronger than ever.

Action Steps for Ministry Leaders in the Crisis Zone

  • Acknowledge it. Don’t ignore or spiritualize your season. Name it honestly.

  • Invite help. Seek out a trusted coach, counselor, mentor, or spiritual director.

  • Pursue healing. Deal with wounds, not just symptoms. Let God go deep.

  • Rediscover identity. Re-root your life in who you are in Christ—not what you do.

  • Wait on clarity. Let new vision and direction come in God’s time, not your rush.

There Is Hope. There Is More.

If you're a ministry leader navigating a Caution or Crisis season, you’re not alone. Many have walked this road—and by God’s grace, come out renewed and ready for the next season of life and leadership.

You can too.

Need support?

Remember: This isn’t the end of your story. It’s the turning point.

God is writing something new—right here in the badlands.

 
Catherine Fitzgerald
Next

Recognizing and Preventing Pastoral Burnout